Hero Slide

Climate and Environmental Dispute Resolution

FedArb provides mediation, arbitration and special master services for complex climate and environmental disputes in the U.S. and internationally.

These matters often turn on competing scientific evidence, regulatory obligations and how contracts allocate responsibility among multiple parties. FedArb’s former federal judges and senior practitioners bring the judgment that comes from handling complex environmental and commercial matters. We help counsel select a neutral whose experience fits the dispute and structure the proceedings around the questions that need to be resolved.

Climate and Environmental Practice Leads

Jerome Roth, FCIArb

Jerome Roth, FCIArb

Roth leads FedArb’s European desk and brings four decades of experience in cross-border disputes to his work as an international arbitrator and mediator. As a partner at Munger, Tolles & Olson, he handled environmental litigation and investigations, including matters involving the Deepwater Horizon oil spill and an offshore seepage incident in Brazil.
View Jerome Roth’s Bio

Hon. Elizabeth H. Emerson (Ret.)

Hon. Elizabeth H. Emerson (Ret.)

Justice Emerson established the Suffolk County Commercial Division of the New York State Supreme Court and presided there for 21 years, hearing complex business disputes. She was selected to represent New York in the Judicial Leaders in Climate Science program.
View Justice Emerson’s Bio

View All Climate and Environmental Panelists

Climate and Environmental Matters We Handle

Our panelists experience as judges, counsel, arbitrators and mediators includes:

  • Site and groundwater contamination, oil spills and other pollution disputes
  • Superfund (CERCLA) cleanup, remediation obligations and allocation of cleanup costs
  • Insurance coverage for environmental pollution
  • Water rights, wetlands mitigation and land use disputes
  • Environmental assessments and stormwater obligations in energy, infrastructure and development projects
  • Disputes over renewable energy credits and other environmental attribute credits
  • Disputes involving environmental compliance and related corporate disclosures

Mediation, Arbitration and Special Master Services

Our panelists experience as judges, counsel, arbitrators and mediators includes:

Mediation helps parties agree on who will perform cleanup, how costs will be shared and how progress will be monitored.
Arbitration resolves disputes over pollution coverage, remediation obligations and environmental terms in project contracts.
Special master services help courts manage discovery and expert disclosures in multiparty environmental litigation.

Climate and Environmental Dispute Resolution FAQs

Yes. Mediation can help potentially responsible parties agree on how to share investigation and cleanup costs, who will perform the remediation and how to address future expenses. The parties can structure an agreement around applicable regulatory requirements and approvals.

Yes. FedArb panelists have mediated and arbitrated disputes involving insurance coverage for environmental pollution. FedArb can help counsel identify a neutral with experience in both insurance coverage and environmental matters.

A court-appointed special master can help manage discovery when a case involves multiple parties, extensive site records or competing expert analyses. Depending on the court’s appointment order, a special master may oversee document production, address discovery disputes or coordinate expert disclosures.

Arbitrators can ask experts to identify where they agree and disagree, then focus the hearing on disputed questions such as where contamination originated, how it spread and what damage it caused.

Yes, when the dispute falls within an applicable arbitration agreement. These disputes can involve whether the seller delivered the credits on time or whether the credits met the buyer’s contractual requirements. FedArb’s panel includes experience with renewable energy credit disputes.

Yes. FedArb can help counsel identify arbitrators based on the governing law, applicable rules, language of the proceedings and industry involved. Jerome Roth, a co-lead of the practice, is an international arbitrator and mediator whose work as counsel included environmental matters in the U.S. and Brazil.

FedArb starts with the issues likely to drive the outcome, such as cleanup cost allocation, pollution coverage or environmental obligations under a project contract. We help counsel identify panelists whose subject matter experience fits the dispute and whose background suits the role they will serve.